Construction Lawyer & Building Solicitors Sydney | Contracts Specialist Law Firm

Understanding Waiver in Construction Contracts: Lessons from DCR Constructions v Matthews

Can a Builder Issue Invoices Not in Accordance with Contract Terms?

Understanding your legal rights when builders fail to comply with contractual progress payment schedules in NSW construction projects.

You can be confident that you are getting the right legal advice.

The DCR Constructions v Matthews case provides critical guidance for homeowners about builders' obligations to issue compliant invoices according to agreed progress payment schedules. This tribunal decision clarifies your rights to insist on contract compliance and the legal implications when builders attempt to circumvent contractual payment terms.

BOOK YOUR FIRST FREE CONSULT

The Case of DCR Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd t/as True Built v Matthews

In this significant NSW construction law case, a homeowner contracted a builder to construct an extension to his home, and the parties agreed on a progress payment schedule. The builder issued several invoices during the construction process, but critically, they did not comply with the contract's terms governing progress payments.

The homeowner paid some of these non-compliant invoices initially. However, he repeatedly informed the builder that he required a proper progress payment schedule and for invoices to be issued only when work was completed at the end of each progress stage, as contractually agreed.

Eventually, the builder issued an invoice for work that he claimed was complete, but the homeowner disputed this claim. The builder then suspended work and purported to terminate the contract under Clause 33 for alleged non-payment of invoices 163 and 174.

The homeowner disputed the builder's termination of the contract and brought the matter before the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). The tribunal examined the terms of the contract, relevant case law principles, and the conduct of both parties before reaching its decision.

Key Tribunal Findings

  • The builder had breached the contract by failing to issue invoices in accordance with the agreed progress payment schedule.
  • The homeowner had not waived his rights to insist on compliance with the contract's terms regarding invoice issuance and progress payments.
  • The tribunal applied established waiver doctrine principles from Australian case law to determine the homeowner's consistent objections preserved his contractual rights despite making some interim payments.
  • The builder's purported termination of the contract was not lawful under the contractual provisions or general law principles.
BOOK YOUR FIRST FREE CONSULT

Clause 15 of the Contract: Progress Payment Requirements

Whilst the case does not expressly refer to the Master Builders Association BC4 contract, the terms referred to in the tribunal decision coincide with the terms from the MBA BC4 contract. Understanding these contractual provisions is essential for homeowners to protect their rights during construction projects.

What Clause 15 Governs

In the DCR Constructions v Matthews case, the tribunal's decision analysed clause 15 of the construction contract in detail.

Clause 15 deals with payment of monies by the homeowner under the contract in regard to progress payments. This clause establishes the procedure for progress payments, which are payments made by the homeowner to the builder at specific, agreed-upon stages of the construction project.

Builder's Obligations Under Clause 15

The contractual framework imposes clear obligations on builders regarding how and when they may claim payment:

  • Clause 15.2: The homeowner must pay the builder "the contract price progressively as claimed by the builder". This means that the builder can claim payment from the homeowner for work that has been completed up to a certain point in the project.
  • Clause 15.3: The builder must give the homeowner a written claim for a progress payment for the substantial completion of each stage. This means that the builder must provide the homeowner with an invoice for the work that has been completed up to a certain point in the project.
  • Clause 15.4: A progress claim must state specific information to be valid and enforceable.

Required Information in Progress Claims

These MBA BC4 contract requirements establish strict compliance obligations for builders claiming progress payments under Australian construction law frameworks. Under clause 15.4, a compliant progress claim must clearly state:

  • The amount claimed and not paid for the stages substantially completed;
  • The amount claimed and not paid for the contract price adjustments;
  • The amount claimed and not paid for variations; and
  • The sum of the above amounts.

These requirements exist to protect homeowners by ensuring transparency in payment claims and preventing builders from demanding payment for incomplete work or work not corresponding to the agreed progress payment schedule.

Under the NSW Home Building Act 1989, these progress payment protections form essential consumer safeguards that builders must comply with when claiming payment from residential homeowners.

The Case: DCR Constructions v Matthews - Detailed Analysis

The Builder's Non-Compliance

In the DCR Constructions case, the builder failed to issue invoices that complied with the terms of the contract. The homeowner had agreed to an amended progress payment schedule on or about 3 January 2017, which established clear milestones for when payment could be claimed.

However, the builder issued invoices that did not correspond to the agreed progress payment schedule, and critically, did not provide sufficient information about the work that had been completed at each stage. This meant the homeowner could not properly verify whether the claimed work had actually been substantially completed.

This failure constituted a fundamental breach of the builder's contractual obligations under clause 15 and prevented the homeowner from verifying substantial completion of each progress stage before payment.

The Homeowner's Consistent Position

The homeowner made his expectations clear to the builder throughout the construction process. He wanted a proper progress payment schedule in respect of the work to construct the extension, and wanted the builder to issue invoices only when work was complete at the end of each progress stage, as contractually required.

Despite these clear communications, the builder insisted on payment of the invoices when they were rendered, rather than at the end of each progress stage of the work as the contract stipulated. This created ongoing tension and ultimately led to the dispute.

The Builder's Waiver Argument

The builder argued that the homeowner had waived his right to rely upon clause 15 of the written contract regarding the issue of progress payments. The builder's reasoning was that because the homeowner paid some invoices during the course of the build without insisting the builder comply with clause 15, he had given up his contractual rights.

However, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the homeowner had waived his rights to rely upon the issue of invoices in accordance with the amended progress payment schedule that he had agreed to on or about 3 January 2017. The tribunal found that paying some non-compliant invoices while consistently objecting to the builder's approach did not constitute a waiver of contractual rights.

The Tribunal's Decision: Protecting Homeowner Rights

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) delivered a decision that strongly affirmed homeowners' rights to insist on contractual compliance regarding progress payments.

Primary Findings

The Tribunal found that the builder did not lawfully terminate the contract under the provisions of the written contract. This finding had significant implications for both parties, as an unlawful termination can expose the terminating party to breach of contract claims.

The Tribunal was satisfied that the homeowner had not elected to waive contractual rights under clause 15 of the written contract. The tribunal examined the legal principles of waiver carefully and determined that the homeowner's conduct did not demonstrate a clear intention to abandon his contractual rights.

The Tribunal also found that the homeowner's conduct in paying some invoices rendered by the builder during the course of the works that were served before completion of a progress stage for works did not constitute estoppel. Estoppel is a legal principle that can prevent a party from asserting their rights if their conduct has led the other party to rely on a different state of affairs to their detriment.

Application of Legal Principles

The tribunal's analysis demonstrates that homeowners who pay non-compliant invoices whilst continuing to assert their rights to proper progress claims do not automatically lose those contractual protections. Consistent objection to non-compliant invoicing practices, even whilst making some payments, can preserve a homeowner's legal position.

The estoppel doctrine requires clear evidence that the builder relied on the homeowner's conduct to their detriment, which was not established in this case despite partial invoice payments during construction.

Implications for NSW Homeowners: Protecting Your Rights

The DCR Constructions v Matthews case provides essential guidance for homeowners engaged in construction projects across New South Wales. Understanding these principles can prevent disputes and protect your financial interests.

While the Security of Payment Act 1999 establishes payment claim frameworks for construction contracts, homeowners retain contractual rights to insist on compliance with agreed progress payment schedules under the Home Building Act 1989.

Key Protective Strategies

This case highlights the critical importance of ensuring that your builder complies with the terms of your construction contract, particularly in relation to progress payments. If your builder fails to issue invoices in accordance with the contract, this can have a significant impact on the progress of your construction project, and may result in legal disputes that could have been avoided.

As a homeowner engaged in or considering a construction project in NSW, it is essential to understand and protect your contractual rights from the outset.

Essential Steps for Homeowners

  • Ensure that the progress payment schedule is agreed upon and included in the contract before signing;
  • Insist that the builder complies with the written contract throughout the construction process;
  • Maintain clear written communications documenting any objections to non-compliant invoices;
  • Do not assume that paying some non-compliant invoices automatically waives your right to insist on proper compliance;
  • Seek specialist construction law advice before signing any building contract to ensure your interests are protected;
  • If disputes arise regarding progress payments, obtain legal advice promptly before the situation escalates; and
  • Prepare comprehensive documentation of all payment disputes, invoice correspondence, and objections for potential NCAT proceedings to establish your consistent position on contract compliance; and

Early legal advice on contract terms and progress payment schedule can prevent expensive disputes and protect your rights throughout the construction process. A specialist construction lawyer can review your contract before you sign and identify any problematic payment provisions.

Understanding Builder Termination Rights and Lawful Termination Requirements

The DCR Constructions v Matthews case provides critical guidance on when builders can lawfully terminate construction contracts for non-payment under NSW construction law. Builders cannot terminate contracts simply because homeowners refuse to pay non-compliant invoices that fail to meet contractual progress payment requirements.

Under standard MBA BC4 contract terms and the Home Building Act 1989, builders must first issue compliant progress claims that satisfy clause 15 requirements before termination rights arise. If invoices do not correspond to the agreed progress payment schedule or lack required information about substantially completed stages, homeowners have lawful grounds to withhold payment without triggering termination provisions.

Unlawful termination by builders exposes them to significant legal consequences including breach of contract claims, damages for wrongful termination, and potential liability for homeowner losses caused by the premature work stoppage. The tribunal in DCR Constructions confirmed that builders who terminate based on non-payment of non-compliant invoices act without lawful authority under the contract.

Homeowners facing threatened termination by builders should immediately obtain specialist construction law advice to assess whether the builder's progress claims comply with contractual requirements and whether any purported termination notice is legally valid under NSW construction legislation and contract terms.

Case Law Relied Upon by the Tribunal

The tribunal's decision in DCR Constructions v Matthews relied on established legal principles from the following significant cases. These precedents establish the framework for determining waiver and estoppel in contractual disputes:

Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 46; (2013) 250 CLR 303

High Court authority on the requirements for establishing waiver of contractual rights.

Craine v Colonial Mutual Fire Insurance Company Ltd (1920) 28 CLR 305

Foundational case law on waiver principles in contractual relationships.

Walton Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher [1988] HCA 7; (1988) 164 CLR 387

Leading High Court authority on the doctrine of estoppel and reliance.

Related content: Understanding Waiver in Construction Contracts: Key Lessons from DCR Constructions v Matthews and Corbett Court Pty Ltd v Quasar Constructions

John Dela Cruz, Principal Lawyer at Contracts Specialist
John Dela Cruz
Principal Lawyer, Contracts Specialist

Why Choose Contracts Specialist

When you work with Contracts Specialist, you receive legal advice directly from John Dela Cruz — Principal Lawyer with over 17 years of exclusive construction law experience.

John is an Australian Legal Practitioner and he services NSW, Queensland, Victoria, and Tasmania. He has dedicated his entire legal career to specialise in construction law. As a former Divisional President of the Master Builders Association NSW, he combines deep legal expertise with comprehensive industry knowledge. He maintains daily experience in building dispute tribunals (NCAT, VCAT, QCAT, TASCAT) and courts across multiple jurisdictions.

Unlike generalist lawyers who handle various legal matters, John specialises exclusively in construction law matters affecting homeowners, builders, contractors, and subcontractors. You receive focused expertise from a lawyer who understands both the legal framework and the practical realities of the building industry.

Frequently Asked Questions About Builder Invoice Compliance and Contract Terms

Can a builder issue invoices that don't match the agreed progress payment schedule in my NSW building contract?

No. Under NSW building contracts, builders must issue invoices in accordance with the agreed progress payment schedule. The DCR Constructions v Matthews case confirms that builders cannot unilaterally change the agreed invoicing process. If your contract includes a progress payment schedule under clause 15 or similar provisions, the builder must comply with those terms when claiming payment. Invoices must correspond to the substantial completion of specified stages and include the required information as set out in the contract.

If I pay some non-compliant invoices from my builder, do I lose my right to insist on proper progress claims later?

Not necessarily. The DCR Constructions v Matthews case establishes that paying some non-compliant invoices whilst consistently objecting to the builder's invoicing practices does not automatically constitute a waiver of your contractual rights. The key factor is whether your conduct demonstrates a clear intention to abandon your contractual rights. If you maintain written objections and consistently assert your right to proper progress claims in accordance with the contract, you may preserve your legal position even if you have made some payments.

What information must a builder include in a valid progress claim under clause 15 of my building contract?

Under clause 15.4 of standard building contracts (such as MBA BC4), a valid progress claim must state: (1) the amount claimed and not paid for the stages substantially completed; (2) the amount claimed and not paid for contract price adjustments; (3) the amount claimed and not paid for variations; and (4) the sum of the above amounts. This information allows you to verify that the claimed work corresponds to the agreed progress payment schedule and that payment is only being claimed for work actually completed.

Can a builder lawfully terminate my building contract if I refuse to pay invoices that don't comply with the contract terms?

No. The DCR Constructions v Matthews case confirms that a builder cannot lawfully terminate a contract for non-payment of invoices that do not comply with the contractual requirements for progress claims. If your builder has issued invoices that do not match the agreed progress payment schedule or do not include the required information under clause 15, you are entitled to withhold payment until compliant invoices are issued. A termination based on non-payment of non-compliant invoices would be unlawful and could expose the builder to breach of contract claims.

What should I do if my builder is issuing invoices that don't match our agreed progress payment schedule?

If your builder is issuing non-compliant invoices, you should: (1) review your building contract carefully to confirm the agreed progress payment schedule and clause 15 requirements; (2) communicate in writing to the builder that the invoices do not comply with the contract terms and request compliant progress claims; (3) maintain records of all communications documenting your objections; (4) do not assume that making payments waives your rights if you continue to assert them; and (5) seek specialist construction law advice promptly. Early legal advice can prevent disputes from escalating and protect your rights to insist on contractual compliance throughout the construction process.

How can I verify whether my builder's progress claim complies with clause 15 requirements before making payment?

To verify clause 15 compliance, check that the builder's invoice corresponds to a substantially completed stage in your agreed progress payment schedule, includes itemised amounts for completed stages, contract price adjustments, and variations as required under clause 15.4, and provides sufficient detail to confirm the work claimed has actually been completed to the specified progress stage. Request supporting documentation such as photographs, statutory declarations, or compliance certificates if the invoice lacks clear evidence of substantial stage completion. If the builder cannot demonstrate substantial completion of the claimed progress stage or the invoice does not match your agreed payment schedule, you have lawful grounds under NSW construction law to withhold payment until a compliant progress claim is issued. Seek specialist construction law advice before withholding payment to ensure your position is legally protected and properly documented.

How can specialist construction law advice help me before signing a building contract?

A specialist construction lawyer can review your building contract before you sign to identify problematic payment provisions, ensure the progress payment schedule is clearly defined and fair, explain your rights and obligations under clause 15 and similar provisions, advise on any unfair contract terms that should be negotiated, and ensure you understand the invoicing and payment process before committing to the contract. This prevention-first approach is more cost-effective than resolving disputes after problems arise and protects your financial interests throughout the construction project.

What legal principles determine whether I have waived my contractual rights by paying non-compliant invoices?

The legal principles of waiver require clear evidence of an intention to abandon contractual rights. The tribunal in DCR Constructions v Matthews applied established case law principles from cases such as Corbett Court Pty Ltd v Quasar Constructions and Expense Reduction Analysts Group v Armstrong Strategic Marketing. The key question is whether your conduct, viewed objectively, demonstrates a clear and unequivocal intention to give up your contractual rights. Paying some invoices whilst continuing to object and assert your rights to proper compliance generally does not constitute waiver. Similarly, the doctrine of estoppel requires that the other party has relied on your conduct to their detriment, which is a high threshold to meet in construction payment disputes.

Protect Your Rights in NSW Building Contracts

Understanding your contractual rights regarding progress payments and builder invoice compliance is essential to protecting your financial interests in any NSW construction project. The DCR Constructions v Matthews case demonstrates the importance of insisting on contractual compliance from the outset and maintaining clear documentation of your position.

Whether you are about to sign a building contract, currently dealing with non-compliant invoices from your builder, or facing a payment dispute, specialist construction law advice can clarify your legal position and protect your rights.

Book your free first consultation with John Dela Cruz, Principal Lawyer with over 17 years of exclusive construction law experience across NSW. During your consultation, we will discuss your specific situation, review any relevant documents, and explain your legal rights and options under NSW building legislation and your contract terms.

Early advice prevents expensive disputes. Free first consultation. No obligation. Just clarity.

BOOK YOUR FIRST FREE CONSULT
Can a Builder Issue Invoices Not in Accordance with Contract Terms?
Fill Out the Form to Download
Can a Builder Issue Invoices Not in Accordance with Contract Terms?
The Complete Handbook for Homeowners: Navigating Construction Law in New South Wales

If you’re a homeowner in New South Wales, it’s crucial to understand Construction Law to protect your investment. This ultimate guide to Construction Law is specifically designed to provide homeowners with essential insights into the legal landscape of home building in NSW.

The Complete Handbook for Homeowners: Navigating Construction Law in New South Wales

If you’re a homeowner in New South Wales, it’s crucial to understand Construction Law to protect your investment. This ultimate guide to Construction Law is specifically designed to provide homeowners with essential insights into the legal landscape of home building in NSW.