Overview of Expert Evidence in NCAT Home Building Disputes

When it comes to resolving home building disputes in NCAT, expert evidence can play a critical role in determining the outcome of a case. Expert evidence refers to information presented to the tribunal by a qualified expert, such as an engineer, architect, or builder, in order to help the tribunal understand complex technical issues related to the dispute.

To present expert evidence in NCAT, parties must comply with strict rules and requirements. One of the key requirements is the submission of an expert report, which outlines the expert’s qualifications and experience, the issues in dispute, and the expert’s opinion on those issues. The report must be served on all parties to the dispute, and filed with the tribunal before the hearing.

At the hearing, expert witnesses may be called upon to provide oral evidence and be cross-examined. The role of the expert witness is to assist the tribunal by providing independent, objective, and impartial evidence on the technical issues in dispute. It is important to note that the tribunal is not bound to accept the evidence of any particular expert, and will make its decision based on all of the evidence presented in the case.

Overall, expert evidence can be a valuable tool in resolving home building disputes in NCAT, particularly in cases involving complex technical issues. It is important for parties to carefully consider the requirements and procedures for presenting expert evidence in NCAT, and to seek professional advice if necessary.

Compliance with the Expert Code of Conduct in NCAT Home Building Disputes

Expert witnesses have an essential role to play in NCAT home building disputes, and as such, they are subject to the Expert Code of Conduct in NSW. This code of conduct lays out the duties and responsibilities of expert witnesses, including their obligation to provide independent and unbiased evidence to assist the tribunal in reaching a fair and just decision. Compliance with the code of conduct is mandatory, and expert witnesses are expected to understand and adhere to the requirements when providing expert evidence in NCAT hearings.

Expert witnesses must ensure that their evidence is relevant, reliable, and based on their specialised knowledge and expertise. They are required to disclose any conflicts of interest or any factors that may impact their independence or objectivity. Expert witnesses are also expected to be transparent and honest in their interactions with the tribunal and other parties involved in the dispute resolution process.

Breaching the Expert Code of Conduct can have significant consequences for expert witnesses, including disciplinary action, suspension or cancellation of their accreditation, or legal action against them. Expert witnesses must take their obligations under the code of conduct seriously to ensure that they are fulfilling their duties to the tribunal and assisting in the fair resolution of home building disputes.


In conclusion, expert evidence is an important aspect of NCAT home building disputes. Expert reports and witness testimony can significantly influence the outcome of a dispute, making it crucial to comply with the Expert Code of Conduct in NSW. Expert witnesses have duties and responsibilities, and non-compliance with the code can have severe consequences. If you are involved in a home building dispute, seeking professional advice can help you navigate the process effectively.