What is Repudiation of a Contract?

Contract repudiation occurs when a party to the contract shows an unwillingness or inability to perform substantial obligations under the contract. This conduct is often referred to as renunciation. For instance, if a builder tells a homeowner that they will not complete work on the agreed completion date or that they will not complete work as agreed, then they may be repudiating the contract.

Contract repudiation is considered a breach of contract because it goes against the fundamental principle of a contract, which is to carry out the agreed terms. When a party repudiates a contract, they are not fulfilling their contractual obligations.

As a result, the other party may accept the repudiation and may be entitled to terminate the contract and seek damages for any losses suffered.

Is Repudiation a Breach of Contract?

You may breach a contractual provision of a contract. For example, the contract requires that one person pays the other within 5 days. If the person fails to pay within 5 days, then the contract is breached by the person who owes the money. The contract may provide the innocent party the right to terminate the contract in such circumstance.

However, a repudiation of a contract often arises from breaches of the contract. The innocent party may not have a contractual right to terminate under the contract. In such circumstances, the innocent party may rely on common law right of repudiation to terminate the contract.

The events that give rise to a repudiatory right do not necessarily require the breach of contract. It is necessary to have regard to the surrounding circumstances.

Is Repudiation the Same as Termination?

Repudiation is not the same as termination. Repudiation refers to the conduct or event that enlivens the innocent party’s right to terminate the contract. It is common that the innocent party notifies the party whose conduct is repudiatory to rectify the repudiatory conduct. If the repudiatory conduct is not remedied then the innocent party may accept the repudiation and terminate the contract.

The effect of termination of contract is to bring the contract to an end. So in effect, a person who repudiates a contract may be exposed to the innocent party terminating the contract.

Often, the innocent party would be entitled to claim damages.

What Happens If You Accept Repudiation?

When a party accepts repudiation, the innocent party has the right to terminate the contract. The termination results in the contract being deemed void at common law. It is not possible to sue for repudiation specifically, but rather, one would bring a claim for breach of contract. Damages may be available in such a claim, depending on the circumstances of the case.

Can You Sue for Repudiation?

It is not proper to say that you would sue or commence proceedings against somebody for repudiation. The more appropriate approach would be to characterise the suing of the other person or to bring proceedings for breach of contract.

How Do You Prove a Repudiatory Breach?

It is not a straightforward formula on whether or not conduct gives rise to a repudiatory breach.

Repudiation needs to be considered in the context of the particular time and events. If a person intends to terminate for repudiation, the safer option would be to provide the at-fault party as many opportunities as reasonable as possible to rectify the breach. This is because repudiation has the effect of terminating the contract.

If you fail to lawfully terminate the contract because the evidence does not constitute a repudiation then the other party may accept your repudiation. That is, your unlawful termination gives rise to a repudiation of the contract entitling the other party to terminate.

It is common that when a party terminates a contract, the other party replies with an acceptance of repudiation response. This would leave the issue of who lawfully terminated the contract up to the courts or tribunal to determine.

This is an important warning for any party who wishes to terminate a contract for repudiation.

If you purport to terminate a contract by relying on someone’s repudiation and it is found that you have not done enough to establish that repudiation, then it is easy enough for the other party to say that your conduct of purporting to terminate the contract is a repudiation of the contract.

What Are Repudiatory Damages?

Damages that arise from repudiation are typically direct damages. This is because when you terminate for repudiation, you are likely not terminating based on a contractual term or contractual right. But rather, you are terminating based on a common law right.

Direct damages include any type of damage that immediately flows from the termination. For example, for a homeowner, the damage would be the cost to complete the work in excess of the contract price. An example for a builder or a contractor for direct damages is the cost incurred to date plus their lost profit.

How Do You Identify and Respond to Repudiation of a Contract?

If someone is accusing you of repudiation or repudiatory conduct, then you should respond to the allegations. If you fail to respond to the allegations, then you expose yourself to the other party relying on your failure to properly respond as support and evidence of your repudiatory conduct.

If your conduct is not a repudiation but rather, you invoking your interpretation of the contract, then you should explain your conduct. You should explain the factual and legal grounds that you rely on as your response. Taking these steps will help you mitigate a claim of repudiation against yourself.

How Does the Court Work Out Whether a Party Has Repudiated a Contract?

It can be a complex matter on determining whether or not a party has repudiated the contract. There is high court authority that helps with understanding the principles and elements of repudiation.

The court will look at the conduct of the parties and the surrounding circumstances.

Best Practices for Identifying and Responding to Repudiation of a Contract

To identify repudiation of building contract, you should review the terms of the contract and assess whether one party has clearly indicated they will not perform their obligations. If you suspect repudiation, you should respond in writing and clearly state your interpretation of the contract and the grounds on which you rely. If you fail to respond, it may be construed as evidence of your own repudiatory conduct.

Courts consider various factors when determining if repudiation has occurred, such as whether the conduct is a breach of an essential or non-essential term causing substantial loss, and whether there is a renunciation of the contract. However, each case is unique, and the court will assess the specific facts and events of the case.

For homeowners and builders, it is crucial to document all communication regarding the contract, including any disagreements or disputes. Seek legal advice if you suspect repudiation or if you receive a notice of repudiation. Prompt and effective communication can help mitigate the risk of repudiation and avoid costly legal proceedings.

What Are Some Examples of Repudiation in a Construction Contract?

Homeowner’s Right to Terminate

Some examples of repudiation include where a builder is significantly delayed with the work, where builder is refusing to build the contract scope of work, and when the Builder demands payment for more money then he is entitled to.

Builder's Right to Terminate

Some examples of repudiation where a builder may be able to terminate the contract is when the owner notifies the Builder that the Builder must carry out more work and he is contractually obliged, the Builder should charge less than he is contractually obliged, and when the owner conducts themself in a manner that prevents the Builder from carrying out his contractual obligations.

Repudiation Advice

A contract specialist or a construction lawyer is able to assist homeowners, builders and contractors to assess and advise whether or not there has been a repudiation of a contract. A construction lawyer will also be able to prepare the appropriate notices including breach and rectification notice, as well as, termination notice. Sending legal letters should be done by a person who has experience with their letters being reviewed and determined by a court.

Conclusion

Understanding contract repudiation is essential, especially in the construction industry. It is a complex area of law that requires careful consideration and legal advice. If you find yourself facing issues related to contract repudiation, it is advisable to seek legal advice from a specialist in construction law.

Book a free consultation with our expert construction lawyer to guide you through the complexities of contract repudiation and help you navigate the legal landscape with confidence.

How We Can Help

Repudiation in construction contracts can be complex and may have significant legal and financial consequences. It is important to identify and respond to repudiation promptly.

Homeowners and builders should seek professional assistance from a construction lawyer or contract specialist to assess their rights and obligations and prepare the appropriate notices. Taking action early can help mitigate damages and prevent further breaches

We are Contracts Specialist, a construction law firm with over 10 years of experience in handling construction contract review, breach of contract, contract termination, and building and construction disputes.
Our specialist construction lawyer can provide legal advice on your matter. Book a free consultation with us today.